[{
  "evidence_id": "post_qzajiw",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "qzajiw",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "recruitinghell",
  "published_at": "2021-11-22T02:14:34.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/recruitinghell/comments/qzajiw/ghosted_by_recruiter_is_it_okay_to_go_straight_to/",
  "source_title": "Ghosted by recruiter. Is it okay to go straight to the hiring manager on LinkedIn?",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "cold",
  "channel": "linkedin",
  "timing": "after_recruiter_ghosting",
  "message_mechanism": "status_followup",
  "observed_outcome": "profile_view_no_reply",
  "highest_stage": "1",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "",
  "note": "The manager viewed the profile but did not reply; the recruiter also remained silent."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "post_1sz8omf",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1sz8omf",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "interviews",
  "published_at": "2026-04-29T19:17:17.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/interviews/comments/1sz8omf/had_an_interview_with_someone_i_know_and_i_bombed/",
  "source_title": "Had an interview with someone i know and i bombed it",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "warm",
  "channel": "unspecified_direct",
  "timing": "before_application",
  "message_mechanism": "fit_question",
  "observed_outcome": "interview",
  "highest_stage": "3",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "",
  "note": "A known manager confirmed fit, requested the resume, and later scheduled an interview."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "post_1cnb50r",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1cnb50r",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "recruitinghell",
  "published_at": "2024-05-08T18:05:35.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/recruitinghell/comments/1cnb50r/i_hope_this_company_burns_you_cant_do_this_to/",
  "source_title": "I hope this company burns, you can’t do this to people",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "warm_prior_finalist",
  "channel": "linkedin",
  "timing": "new_opening_after_prior_final",
  "message_mechanism": "renewed_interest",
  "observed_outcome": "reinterview_role_cancelled",
  "highest_stage": "4",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "",
  "note": "The manager prioritized the application and restarted interviews; the role was later cancelled for budget reasons."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "post_1f6l4lg",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1f6l4lg",
  "case_kind": "mixed_aggregate",
  "community": "jobs",
  "published_at": "2024-09-01T18:17:54.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/jobs/comments/1f6l4lg/after_hundreds_and_hundreds_of_applications_i/",
  "source_title": "After hundreds and hundreds of applications, I changed up my job search approach and started getting interviews, and then a job. Here's what I did.",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "mixed_network_and_hiring_managers",
  "relationship": "mixed",
  "channel": "mixed",
  "timing": "before_and_after_application",
  "message_mechanism": "targeted_fit_and_connection",
  "observed_outcome": "more_interviews_and_hired",
  "highest_stage": "5",
  "attribution": "weak_bundled_strategy",
  "text": "",
  "note": "The author changed several tactics at once, reported recruiter calls for most targeted applications, and found a job in two months."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "post_1pcy83t",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1pcy83t",
  "case_kind": "mixed_aggregate",
  "community": "biotech",
  "published_at": "2025-12-03T07:48:37.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/biotech/comments/1pcy83t/success_story_despite_this_godforsaken_market/",
  "source_title": "Success Story Despite This Godforsaken Market",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "mixed_referrals_and_managers",
  "relationship": "mixed",
  "channel": "mixed",
  "timing": "mixed",
  "message_mechanism": "referral_and_direct_outreach",
  "observed_outcome": "two_offers",
  "highest_stage": "5",
  "attribution": "weak_bundled_sources",
  "text": "",
  "note": "The author reported 58 applications, 14 screens, 6 finals, and 2 offers, but grouped referrals with direct outreach."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "post_tbuthh_case_1",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "tbuthh",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "EngineeringStudents",
  "published_at": "2022-03-11T17:12:00.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/EngineeringStudents/comments/tbuthh/you_should_always_ask_why_you_got_rejected_it_has/",
  "source_title": "You should always ask why you got rejected. It has landed me 1 FT position, 1 internships and now another interview",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "in_person_recontact",
  "channel": "job_fair",
  "timing": "after_rejection",
  "message_mechanism": "specific_feedback_request",
  "observed_outcome": "new_interview_and_internship",
  "highest_stage": "5",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "",
  "note": "A feedback request after rejection reopened the process and led to an internship offer."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "post_tbuthh_case_2",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "tbuthh",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "EngineeringStudents",
  "published_at": "2022-03-11T17:12:00.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/EngineeringStudents/comments/tbuthh/you_should_always_ask_why_you_got_rejected_it_has/",
  "source_title": "You should always ask why you got rejected. It has landed me 1 FT position, 1 internships and now another interview",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "cold",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "after_rejection",
  "message_mechanism": "specific_feedback_request",
  "observed_outcome": "ats_error_found_interview_and_hired",
  "highest_stage": "5",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "",
  "note": "The manager found that software had cut the resume in half, accepted a corrected copy, and hired the candidate after an interview."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "post_tbuthh_case_3",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "tbuthh",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "EngineeringStudents",
  "published_at": "2022-03-11T17:12:00.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/EngineeringStudents/comments/tbuthh/you_should_always_ask_why_you_got_rejected_it_has/",
  "source_title": "You should always ask why you got rejected. It has landed me 1 FT position, 1 internships and now another interview",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "recruiter",
  "relationship": "cold",
  "channel": "online_message",
  "timing": "after_rejection",
  "message_mechanism": "specific_feedback_request",
  "observed_outcome": "resume_forwarded_to_manager",
  "highest_stage": "2",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "",
  "note": "The recruiter forwarded the resume to the hiring manager after a feedback request."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "post_12kuggx",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "12kuggx",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "recruitinghell",
  "published_at": "2023-04-13T16:19:09.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/recruitinghell/comments/12kuggx/hiring_manager_told_me_no_special_treatment_when/",
  "source_title": "Hiring manager told me “no special treatment” when I sent them a message after applying.",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "cold",
  "channel": "linkedin",
  "timing": "after_application",
  "message_mechanism": "generic_interest",
  "observed_outcome": "negative_reply_no_progression",
  "highest_stage": "2",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "",
  "note": "One manager replied that external candidates receive no special treatment; the author also reported unspecified appreciative replies elsewhere."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "post_sqwe04",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "sqwe04",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "jobs",
  "published_at": "2022-02-12T17:20:09.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/jobs/comments/sqwe04/took_a_chance_dmd_hiring_manager_of_major_saas/",
  "source_title": "Took a chance, DM’d hiring manager of major SaaS company, responded immediately with a calendar invite to meet- nervous and need advice",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "cold",
  "channel": "linkedin",
  "timing": "in_response_to_manager_job_post",
  "message_mechanism": "specific_fit",
  "observed_outcome": "immediate_manager_meeting",
  "highest_stage": "3",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "",
  "note": "A direct message tied to the manager's own job post produced an immediate calendar invitation."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "post_1k5jx6a",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1k5jx6a",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "jobsearchhacks",
  "published_at": "2025-04-22T22:47:17.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/jobsearchhacks/comments/1k5jx6a/got_an_interview_by_emailing_the_hiring_manager/",
  "source_title": "Got an interview by emailing the hiring manager update!",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "cold",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "after_application",
  "message_mechanism": "unspecified_outreach",
  "observed_outcome": "interview_and_second_round_signal",
  "highest_stage": "4",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "",
  "note": "The employer said it interviewed everyone who contacted the team by LinkedIn or email because it interpreted outreach as initiative."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "post_1kfs6zq",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1kfs6zq",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "jobs",
  "published_at": "2025-05-06T01:04:32.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/jobs/comments/1kfs6zq/pro_tip_get_rejected_faster_when_you_reach_out_to/",
  "source_title": "\"Pro\" tip: Get rejected faster when you reach out to the hiring manager on Linkedin!",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "cold",
  "channel": "linkedin",
  "timing": "after_application",
  "message_mechanism": "unspecified_outreach",
  "observed_outcome": "rejection_within_one_day",
  "highest_stage": "1",
  "attribution": "uncertain_temporal_association",
  "text": "",
  "note": "The author repeatedly received quick rejections after outreach; this may reflect accelerated review rather than harm caused by contact."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "post_1gux473",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1gux473",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "torontoJobs",
  "published_at": "2024-11-19T13:28:34.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/torontoJobs/comments/1gux473/cold_emailing_hiring_managers_my_resume_does_it/",
  "source_title": "Cold Emailing Hiring Managers My Resume - Does it work?",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "cold",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "around_application",
  "message_mechanism": "resume_and_fit_note",
  "observed_outcome": "no_replies_one_profile_view",
  "highest_stage": "1",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "",
  "note": "Fewer than ten emails produced no replies; one manager viewed the LinkedIn profile."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "post_113ds1a",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "113ds1a",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "recruitinghell",
  "published_at": "2023-02-16T00:56:34.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/recruitinghell/comments/113ds1a/isnt_it_unprofessional_to_email_a_hiring_manager/",
  "source_title": "Isn’t it unprofessional to email a hiring manager at their work email after applying for a job?",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "cold",
  "channel": "linkedin",
  "timing": "after_application",
  "message_mechanism": "generic_interest",
  "observed_outcome": "six_messages_no_reply",
  "highest_stage": "1",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "",
  "note": "Six managers accepted connection requests but did not answer the followup message."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "post_1n7des8",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1n7des8",
  "case_kind": "mixed_aggregate",
  "community": "jobsearchhacks",
  "published_at": "2025-09-03T12:26:44.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/jobsearchhacks/comments/1n7des8/landed_my_dream_job/",
  "source_title": "Landed my Dream Job",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "cold",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "targeted_application",
  "message_mechanism": "researched_cover_letter",
  "observed_outcome": "reported_high_interview_rate_and_hired",
  "highest_stage": "5",
  "attribution": "weak_self_reported_aggregate",
  "text": "",
  "note": "The author reported first stage interviews for about three quarters of targeted applications and said the strategy led to a dream job."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "post_1qre715",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1qre715",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "recruitinghell",
  "published_at": "2026-01-30T18:47:03.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/recruitinghell/comments/1qre715/finally_got_a_job_after_26_months_of_searching/",
  "source_title": "FINALLY got a job after 26 months of searching!",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "cold",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "after_application",
  "message_mechanism": "role_specific_work_sample",
  "observed_outcome": "hired",
  "highest_stage": "5",
  "attribution": "plausible_but_bundled_with_resume_change",
  "text": "",
  "note": "A short note with work directly mapped to the role accompanied an ATS optimized application and preceded a hire."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "post_f8mf9",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "f8mf9",
  "case_kind": "comparator",
  "community": "jobs",
  "published_at": "2011-01-25T09:35:14.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/jobs/comments/f8mf9/recruiter_didnt_submit_me_for_a_job_so_i_applied/",
  "source_title": "Recruiter didn't submit me for a job, so I applied directly and got it. Are there any problems with this?",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "company_application",
  "relationship": "cold",
  "channel": "application_site",
  "timing": "after_recruiter_declined_submission",
  "message_mechanism": "direct_application",
  "observed_outcome": "hired_at_higher_level",
  "highest_stage": "5",
  "attribution": "not_manager_outreach",
  "text": "",
  "note": "This is a recruiter bypass case, not direct manager outreach, and is retained only as a comparator."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "post_aj9p1a",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "aj9p1a",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "ITCareerQuestions",
  "published_at": "2019-01-24T06:33:06.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/ITCareerQuestions/comments/aj9p1a/hr_rejects_resumes_no_rhyme_or_reason_networking/",
  "source_title": "HR rejects resumes, no rhyme or reason. Networking is important..",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "warm_referral",
  "channel": "email_by_employee_contact",
  "timing": "after_ats_rejections",
  "message_mechanism": "resume_forwarded_with_job_ids",
  "observed_outcome": "four_interviews_two_second_rounds",
  "highest_stage": "4",
  "attribution": "direct_but_referral_not_cold",
  "text": "",
  "note": "A weak tie inside the company emailed the resume and job identifiers to managers after repeated system rejections."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "post_1lfou0a",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1lfou0a",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "cscareers",
  "published_at": "2025-06-19T23:08:04.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/cscareers/comments/1lfou0a/linkedin_is_a_powerful_tool_for_finding_jobs/",
  "source_title": "Linkedin is a powerful tool for finding jobs",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "cold",
  "channel": "linkedin",
  "timing": "after_application",
  "message_mechanism": "product_interest_and_skill_overlap",
  "observed_outcome": "recruiter_screen_and_panel_no_offer",
  "highest_stage": "4",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "",
  "note": "The manager sent the resume to recruiting and later advanced the candidate to a panel despite failed technical screens; no offer followed."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "post_1c9j8zl",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1c9j8zl",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "cscareerquestionsuk",
  "published_at": "2024-04-21T14:30:07.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/cscareerquestionsuk/comments/1c9j8zl/getting_job_from_a_bootcamp_my_advice/",
  "source_title": "Getting job from a bootcamp: My advice",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "cold",
  "channel": "linkedin",
  "timing": "around_application",
  "message_mechanism": "specific_interest",
  "observed_outcome": "hired",
  "highest_stage": "5",
  "attribution": "uncertain_author_suspects_help",
  "text": "",
  "note": "A bootcamp graduate messaged the manager and later got the developer job, but only suspected that the message helped secure the interview."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "post_1psb3b0",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1psb3b0",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "recruitinghell",
  "published_at": "2025-12-21T16:54:12.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/recruitinghell/comments/1psb3b0/got_a_job_offer/",
  "source_title": "Got a Job Offer!",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "cold",
  "channel": "email_listed_in_posting",
  "timing": "around_application",
  "message_mechanism": "unspecified_direct_contact",
  "observed_outcome": "hired",
  "highest_stage": "5",
  "attribution": "uncertain_correlation",
  "text": "",
  "note": "The author directly contacted the manager using an address in the posting and later received an offer."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "post_1dbaxrh",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1dbaxrh",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "recruiting",
  "published_at": "2024-06-08T19:38:34.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/recruiting/comments/1dbaxrh/this_is_crazy/",
  "source_title": "This is crazy",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "cold",
  "channel": "linkedin",
  "timing": "after_application",
  "message_mechanism": "unspecified_outreach",
  "observed_outcome": "manager_interest_then_recruiter_screen_and_rejection",
  "highest_stage": "3",
  "attribution": "direct_for_access_not_final_outcome",
  "text": "",
  "note": "The manager wanted to speak but required the normal recruiter screen first; the candidate was later rejected."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "comment_lruh45y",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "comment",
  "source_id": "lruh45y",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "Switzerland",
  "published_at": "2024-10-14T08:07:59.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/Switzerland/comments/1g3amqp/is_reaching_out_to_the_manager_seen_as_a_bad/lruh45y/",
  "source_title": "Is reaching out to the manager seen as a bad manner here ?",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "cold",
  "channel": "linkedin",
  "timing": "after_application",
  "message_mechanism": "application_visibility",
  "observed_outcome": "interview_then_contract",
  "highest_stage": "5",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "",
  "note": "The commenter reported an interview one week after outreach and a contract one week later."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "comment_j97bgk2",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "comment",
  "source_id": "j97bgk2",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "recruitinghell",
  "published_at": "2023-02-19T20:26:30.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/recruitinghell/comments/113ds1a/isnt_it_unprofessional_to_email_a_hiring_manager/j97bgk2/",
  "source_title": "Isn’t it unprofessional to email a hiring manager at their work email after applying for a job?",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "department_head",
  "relationship": "cold",
  "channel": "linkedin",
  "timing": "after_job_posting",
  "message_mechanism": "specific_industry_fit_and_projects",
  "observed_outcome": "reply_next_day_and_final_stage",
  "highest_stage": "4",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "",
  "note": "A highly matched candidate received a next day reply and reported reaching the final stage."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "comment_k7a0zr6",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "comment",
  "source_id": "k7a0zr6",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "recruitinghell",
  "published_at": "2023-10-31T20:32:46.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/recruitinghell/comments/113ds1a/isnt_it_unprofessional_to_email_a_hiring_manager/k7a0zr6/",
  "source_title": "Isn’t it unprofessional to email a hiring manager at their work email after applying for a job?",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "recruiter",
  "relationship": "warm_email_source",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "after_rejection",
  "message_mechanism": "qualification_or_data_error_question",
  "observed_outcome": "interview_then_offer",
  "highest_stage": "5",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "",
  "note": "A request to correct possible misinformation after rejection led to an interview and an offer."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "comment_lruhjl4",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "comment",
  "source_id": "lruhjl4",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "Switzerland",
  "published_at": "2024-10-14T08:13:26.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/Switzerland/comments/1g3amqp/is_reaching_out_to_the_manager_seen_as_a_bad/lruhjl4/",
  "source_title": "Is reaching out to the manager seen as a bad manner here ?",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "company",
  "relationship": "cold",
  "channel": "unsolicited_application",
  "timing": "without_opening",
  "message_mechanism": "carefully_targeted_cover_letter",
  "observed_outcome": "hired_and_retained_seven_years",
  "highest_stage": "5",
  "attribution": "direct_but_industry_specific",
  "text": "",
  "note": "An unsolicited application in law led to a seven year tenure and later partnership."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "comment_gdgssfa_1",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "comment",
  "source_id": "gdgssfa",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "AskEngineers",
  "published_at": "2020-11-24T18:04:11.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/AskEngineers/comments/k09xep/thoughts_on_coldemailing_hiring_managers_if_one/gdgssfa/",
  "source_title": "Thoughts on cold-emailing hiring managers if one can guess their email?",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "cold",
  "channel": "linkedin",
  "timing": "around_application",
  "message_mechanism": "unspecified_direct_contact",
  "observed_outcome": "interview_then_current_job",
  "highest_stage": "5",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "",
  "note": "The commenter linked a direct LinkedIn message to the interview for the current position."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "comment_gdgssfa_2",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "comment",
  "source_id": "gdgssfa",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "AskEngineers",
  "published_at": "2020-11-24T18:04:11.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/AskEngineers/comments/k09xep/thoughts_on_coldemailing_hiring_managers_if_one/gdgssfa/",
  "source_title": "Thoughts on cold-emailing hiring managers if one can guess their email?",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "cold",
  "channel": "linkedin",
  "timing": "around_application",
  "message_mechanism": "unspecified_direct_contact",
  "observed_outcome": "interviews",
  "highest_stage": "3",
  "attribution": "secondhand",
  "text": "",
  "note": "The same commenter reported that a spouse also secured interviews through direct messages."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "comment_o3m8twm",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "comment",
  "source_id": "o3m8twm",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "recruitinghell",
  "published_at": "2026-02-04T22:54:01.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/recruitinghell/comments/1qv29u1/is_there_a_way_to_respectfully_bypass_the/o3m8twm/",
  "source_title": "Is there a way to (respectfully) bypass the recruiter and go straight to the hiring manager?",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "warm_referral",
  "channel": "employee_forward",
  "timing": "before_standard_screen",
  "message_mechanism": "resume_forwarded",
  "observed_outcome": "manager_first_interview",
  "highest_stage": "3",
  "attribution": "direct_but_referral_not_cold",
  "text": "",
  "note": "A former coworker put the resume before the manager, who conducted the first interview."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "comment_nzs5bdy",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "comment",
  "source_id": "nzs5bdy",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "jobhunting",
  "published_at": "2026-01-15T19:15:55.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/jobhunting/comments/1pa24q8/has_anyone_actually_landed_an_interview_by_cold/nzs5bdy/",
  "source_title": "Has anyone actually landed an interview by cold emailing a hiring manager?",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "cold",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "six_days_after_application",
  "message_mechanism": "specific_fit",
  "observed_outcome": "manager_forwarded_to_recruiter_no_later_outcome",
  "highest_stage": "2",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "",
  "note": "The manager asked recruiting to review the application; no interview outcome had been reported."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "comment_o3ekq71",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "comment",
  "source_id": "o3ekq71",
  "case_kind": "hiring_side_perspective",
  "community": "recruitinghell",
  "published_at": "2026-02-03T20:21:24.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/recruitinghell/comments/1qv29u1/is_there_a_way_to_respectfully_bypass_the/o3ekq71/",
  "source_title": "Is there a way to (respectfully) bypass the recruiter and go straight to the hiring manager?",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "cold",
  "channel": "unspecified",
  "timing": "around_application",
  "message_mechanism": "bypass_request",
  "observed_outcome": "reported_slim_chance_of_priority",
  "highest_stage": "0",
  "attribution": "policy_perspective",
  "text": "",
  "note": "A manager said cold contact cannot bypass HR and rarely causes prioritization, while legitimate internal referrals may."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "comment_nrgbc3b",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "comment",
  "source_id": "nrgbc3b",
  "case_kind": "hiring_side_perspective",
  "community": "jobhunting",
  "published_at": "2025-11-29T22:59:10.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/jobhunting/comments/1pa24q8/has_anyone_actually_landed_an_interview_by_cold/nrgbc3b/",
  "source_title": "Has anyone actually landed an interview by cold emailing a hiring manager?",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "manager_or_hr",
  "relationship": "cold",
  "channel": "unspecified",
  "timing": "around_application",
  "message_mechanism": "cold_outreach",
  "observed_outcome": "mild_irritation_usually_not_penalized",
  "highest_stage": "0",
  "attribution": "hiring_side_preference",
  "text": "",
  "note": "A manager and HR practitioner reported irritation from volume but rarely penalized outreach unless aggressive or poor."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "comment_j8qo27j",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "comment",
  "source_id": "j8qo27j",
  "case_kind": "hiring_side_perspective",
  "community": "recruitinghell",
  "published_at": "2023-02-16T06:41:38.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/recruitinghell/comments/113ds1a/isnt_it_unprofessional_to_email_a_hiring_manager/j8qo27j/",
  "source_title": "Isn’t it unprofessional to email a hiring manager at their work email after applying for a job?",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "cold",
  "channel": "linkedin",
  "timing": "before_interview",
  "message_mechanism": "coffee_chat_or_repeated_followup",
  "observed_outcome": "bias_and_irritation_risk",
  "highest_stage": "0",
  "attribution": "hiring_side_preference",
  "text": "",
  "note": "A hiring practitioner avoided preinterview contact to limit bias and described repeated followups as counterproductive."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "comment_lrukqam",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "comment",
  "source_id": "lrukqam",
  "case_kind": "hiring_side_perspective",
  "community": "Switzerland",
  "published_at": "2024-10-14T08:52:54.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/Switzerland/comments/1g3amqp/is_reaching_out_to_the_manager_seen_as_a_bad/lrukqam/",
  "source_title": "Is reaching out to the manager seen as a bad manner here ?",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "cold",
  "channel": "unspecified",
  "timing": "after_application",
  "message_mechanism": "motivation_repeat",
  "observed_outcome": "perceived_special_treatment_and_time_cost",
  "highest_stage": "0",
  "attribution": "hiring_side_preference",
  "text": "",
  "note": "A hiring side commenter viewed redundant outreach as a request for special treatment and an unscalable burden."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "comment_nxvybvd",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "comment",
  "source_id": "nxvybvd",
  "case_kind": "hiring_side_perspective",
  "community": "recruitinghell",
  "published_at": "2026-01-05T21:06:04.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/recruitinghell/comments/113ds1a/isnt_it_unprofessional_to_email_a_hiring_manager/nxvybvd/",
  "source_title": "Isn’t it unprofessional to email a hiring manager at their work email after applying for a job?",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "cold",
  "channel": "linkedin",
  "timing": "after_application",
  "message_mechanism": "application_visibility",
  "observed_outcome": "closer_resume_review",
  "highest_stage": "1",
  "attribution": "hiring_side_process_report",
  "text": "",
  "note": "An experienced hiring practitioner said outreach often caused a closer resume review, while noting that manager preferences vary."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "comment_hlrhhyi",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "comment",
  "source_id": "hlrhhyi",
  "case_kind": "hiring_side_perspective",
  "community": "recruitinghell",
  "published_at": "2021-11-23T13:05:27.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/recruitinghell/comments/qzajiw/ghosted_by_recruiter_is_it_okay_to_go_straight_to/hlrhhyi/",
  "source_title": "Ghosted by recruiter. Is it okay to go straight to the hiring manager on LinkedIn?",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "cold",
  "channel": "linkedin",
  "timing": "around_application",
  "message_mechanism": "unspecified_outreach",
  "observed_outcome": "manager_reactions_vary",
  "highest_stage": "0",
  "attribution": "secondhand_hiring_team_observation",
  "text": "",
  "note": "One recruiting professional observed opposite reactions from different managers in the same organization."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "comment_hlo6qeg",
  "platform": "reddit",
  "source_type": "comment",
  "source_id": "hlo6qeg",
  "case_kind": "hiring_side_perspective",
  "community": "recruitinghell",
  "published_at": "2021-11-22T18:57:58.000Z",
  "source_url": "https://www.reddit.com/r/recruitinghell/comments/qzajiw/ghosted_by_recruiter_is_it_okay_to_go_straight_to/hlo6qeg/",
  "source_title": "Ghosted by recruiter. Is it okay to go straight to the hiring manager on LinkedIn?",
  "author_username": "",
  "contact_target": "hiring_team",
  "relationship": "existing_candidate",
  "channel": "unspecified_followup",
  "timing": "within_promised_wait_window",
  "message_mechanism": "impatient_followup",
  "observed_outcome": "reported_loss_of_job_chance",
  "highest_stage": "0",
  "attribution": "secondhand_claim",
  "text": "",
  "note": "A hiring side commenter said impatience within the communicated decision window cost a candidate the job."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_2054567772177170521",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "2054567772177170521",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Wed May 13 14:21:43 +0000 2026",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/prompterminal/status/2054567772177170521",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "prompterminal",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "after_application",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "no_response",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "So I applied in November to a \"Junior quantum researcher\" position at company X in Montreal and emailed the hiring manager to show my strong interest. I'm a normal person. It's been 6 months, and that position is still open. This is Montreal. Who do they expect to hire for a JUNIOR quantum researcher role? This is ridiculous.",
  "note": "Six months after applying and emailing, the role remained open with no reported reply."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_2037595208377098263",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "2037595208377098263",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Fri Mar 27 18:18:49 +0000 2026",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/EfoEtornam/status/2037595208377098263",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "EfoEtornam",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "unspecified_direct",
  "timing": "before_application",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "offer_or_hire",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "I just got this job without even applying. I reached out to the hiring manager, had a conversation about my interest in the position and that was it😂",
  "note": "Direct conversation led to a job without a formal application."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_2033114492284911856",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "2033114492284911856",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Sun Mar 15 09:34:03 +0000 2026",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/davey_lord1/status/2033114492284911856",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "davey_lord1",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "linkedin",
  "timing": "after_application",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "rejection_or_negative",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "@echotrx Applied for a job which requires exactly what I'm doing in my current job. Reached out to the hiring manager on LinkedIn. \nShe says: the job is very specific(what I already do), so your experience isn't enough.",
  "note": "The manager replied that the experience was insufficient."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_2031020837441057030",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "2031020837441057030",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Mon Mar 09 14:54:36 +0000 2026",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/_deLaaaLi/status/2031020837441057030",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "_deLaaaLi",
  "contact_target": "executive",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "after_application",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "reply_or_process_update",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "i cold emailed the ceo of a US organization because i applied to a role for their Ghana office and he actually replied 😁 \n\ni had done some research and prepared a deck for the role but i couldn’t find a Ghana hiring manager so i just found the ceo & sent it to him. https://t.co/obEolWmPLe",
  "note": "A researched message with a role-specific deck received a reply from the CEO."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1965797756859208037",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1965797756859208037",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Wed Sep 10 15:21:22 +0000 2025",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/brittanycity/status/1965797756859208037",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "brittanycity",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "during_screening",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "offer_or_hire",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "Idk about unhinged Im an angel but.. \nThe role I have now was a role I was screening for at Afrotech, I liked it for myself so I emailed the hiring manager directly rest is history.",
  "note": "Direct email to the manager was part of the path to the current role."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1952306948344357068",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1952306948344357068",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Mon Aug 04 09:53:43 +0000 2025",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/BusinessInsider/status/1952306948344357068",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "BusinessInsider",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "unspecified_direct",
  "timing": "after_rejection",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "offer_or_hire",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "The company rejected my job app. I reached out to the hiring manager anyway — and landed the role. https://t.co/68Sy0enVmY",
  "note": "The candidate contacted the manager after an automated rejection and reports landing the role."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1912231910253740410",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1912231910253740410",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Tue Apr 15 19:49:49 +0000 2025",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/edensvalentina/status/1912231910253740410",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "edensvalentina",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "late_process",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "reply_or_process_update",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "i emailed the hiring manager and she was like “I’ll get back in touch once the union gives me the contract idk when that is though” \nDESPAIR IN THIS HOUSE TONIGHT",
  "note": "The manager replied that a union contract was still pending."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1905702505008472096",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1905702505008472096",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Fri Mar 28 19:24:18 +0000 2025",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/PrayForOomfie/status/1905702505008472096",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "PrayForOomfie",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "unspecified_direct",
  "timing": "after_application",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "reply_or_process_update",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "One good thing that has happened this week is that I reached out to the hiring manager for feedback abt what I can do to get an interview next time & he told me ppl havent been contacted for interviews yet (for the position posted almost 2 months ago) and I'll hear from them l8r",
  "note": "A feedback request produced a status update that interviews had not started."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1890192179982893155",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1890192179982893155",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Fri Feb 14 00:11:48 +0000 2025",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/brownsugabaaaby/status/1890192179982893155",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "brownsugabaaaby",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "after_missed_interview",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "interview_or_screen",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "My baby been sick all week and I ended missing an interview yesterday bc I kept her home. I emailed the hiring manager to apologize and she said she still wanna meet w me next week. \n\nLike even if it’s not the right fit, God, thank you for grace! 🥹😭🙌🏾🙏🏾",
  "note": "An apology email led to the interview being rescheduled."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1884236241534930996",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1884236241534930996",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Tue Jan 28 13:45:02 +0000 2025",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/toddsaunders/status/1884236241534930996",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "toddsaunders",
  "contact_target": "recruiter",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "before_application",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "offer_or_hire",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "My whole career has been built on cold email.\n\nI cold emailed @ariannahuff after she spoke to a group of Interns at AOL which led me asdsad\n\nI cold emailed @VernonDavis85 when he started his interior design company and ended up building his website and doing marketing for him.\n\nI cold emailed a recruiter at Google which is how I got my first job.\n\nAND....I answered a cold email from @parulia which led to @fcollective leading our Series A.\n\nWhen done thoughtfully, cold email isn't spam, it’s an opportunity.\n\nA well written cold email shows initiative and creativity.\n\nDon’t underestimate the doors you can open with a simple, well-written email.\n\nSHOOT YOUR SHOT! It can literally change your life.",
  "note": "The author attributes a first job at Google to a cold email to a recruiter."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1851776168216924322",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1851776168216924322",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Thu Oct 31 00:00:17 +0000 2024",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/burnerc1ty/status/1851776168216924322",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "burnerc1ty",
  "contact_target": "recruiter",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "before_application",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "reply_or_process_update",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "Cold emailed a recruiter so I can get a ref for the PERFECT role and she told me to send in my resume so I DID but I didn’t read the fucking posting well enough and it’s a hybrid role in El Segundo, CA god whyyytt",
  "note": "The recruiter replied and requested a resume, but the role location was unsuitable."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1850230789591429530",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1850230789591429530",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Sat Oct 26 17:39:30 +0000 2024",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/jayanaman/status/1850230789591429530",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "jayanaman",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "direct_message_unspecified",
  "timing": "before_application",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "offer_or_hire",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "How I got my current job?\n\nI cold messaged the hiring manager to congratulate them on joining the company and offered to help if they needed any insights",
  "note": "The author attributes the current job to a cold message to the manager."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1832173436531306897",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1832173436531306897",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Fri Sep 06 21:46:02 +0000 2024",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/pali1216/status/1832173436531306897",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "pali1216",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "after_interview",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "rejection_or_negative",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "I went through three rounds of interviews for one position before getting an email saying they didnt like my resumé enough. Confused, contacted the hiring manager, who said they were indeed rejecting me but just had sent me the wrong rejection email",
  "note": "The manager confirmed rejection and clarified that the wrong rejection template had been sent."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1805460900515570003",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1805460900515570003",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Tue Jun 25 04:39:57 +0000 2024",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/KamdiMiracle/status/1805460900515570003",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "KamdiMiracle",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "unspecified_direct",
  "timing": "after_interview",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "rejection_or_negative",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "This reminds me of a job I was very sure I had \"gotten\" after the interview. When no offer was forthcoming. I reached out to hiring manager. Turns the head of marketing said no because my resume was \"intimidating\". Someone that prolly had like 7+ years. August will be my 4th year",
  "note": "Follow-up revealed that a senior stakeholder had rejected the candidate."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1800606204915528018",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1800606204915528018",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Tue Jun 11 19:09:07 +0000 2024",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/urlichsanais/status/1800606204915528018",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "urlichsanais",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "unspecified_direct",
  "timing": "after_interview",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "feedback_only",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "6) I reached out to the Hiring Manager at Apple after the interview to ask for more feedback on how I could improve. He suggested me this book: \nhttps://t.co/i0YQ7pOpTu\n\nI bought the book. You study to interview, and then you study some more.",
  "note": "The manager replied with a book recommendation for improvement."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1790122009013170371",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1790122009013170371",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Mon May 13 20:48:40 +0000 2024",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/woosanshome/status/1790122009013170371",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "woosanshome",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "after_interview",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "no_response",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "@bambied_ Nah fr I had an interview for a job back in March and have emailed the hiring manager and HR manager and have received nothing back... it's now May and the job still posted on their website🙃🙃",
  "note": "Neither the hiring manager nor HR replied after the interview."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1765179748119146977",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1765179748119146977",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Wed Mar 06 00:57:02 +0000 2024",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/hyunjins/status/1765179748119146977",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "hyunjins",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "direct_message_unspecified",
  "timing": "late_process",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "offer_or_hire",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "i already talked about it on priv but i messaged the hiring manager and they said they are currently creating my offer letter sooooo :D",
  "note": "A message produced confirmation that an offer letter was being prepared."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1743289028391113198",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1743289028391113198",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Fri Jan 05 15:11:07 +0000 2024",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/jmotivator/status/1743289028391113198",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "jmotivator",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "unspecified_direct",
  "timing": "after_rejection",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "feedback_only",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "Fun story:  I graduated from George Mason University and in my past life I was a social worker and looking to get out (as one does) so I applied for a job in HR at George Mason University.  I made it to the last two candidates and was not selected.\n\nI contacted the hiring manager for pointers on what the final decision came down to and the HR manager, without a hint of awareness, told me that the other  candidate was chosen for the job because they \"graduated from a more prestigious school\".",
  "note": "The manager explained the stated reason for selecting another finalist."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1733852612120674520",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1733852612120674520",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Sun Dec 10 14:14:10 +0000 2023",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/philatravelgirl/status/1733852612120674520",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "philatravelgirl",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "unspecified_direct",
  "timing": "after_application",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "offer_or_hire",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "@ImSoSarah Not surprising when i was in job search. Many of my interviews and eventually job were bc i reached out to hiring manager same day as submitting online app. Hiring mgr adds me to interview list while all online apps reject me.",
  "note": "The author reports interviews and an eventual job after same-day outreach."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1672255059936047106",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1672255059936047106",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Fri Jun 23 14:47:29 +0000 2023",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/SpannDaMan/status/1672255059936047106",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "SpannDaMan",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "linkedin",
  "timing": "after_application",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "rejection_or_negative",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "@thunter86 😂😭😂 nah fr I once applied for a job around 10 at night. I commented on the LinkedIn post and messaged the hiring manager.\n9:12am I got the rejection email, like damn I was the first priority of the day? Lol",
  "note": "The candidate was rejected the next morning after applying and messaging."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1632825620051681281",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1632825620051681281",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Mon Mar 06 19:28:58 +0000 2023",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/TheHayzeus/status/1632825620051681281",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "TheHayzeus",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "unspecified_direct",
  "timing": "after_interview",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "reply_or_process_update",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "Today I reached out to the hiring manager about the job I interviewed for and she told me that a decision will be made this week. I’m getting nervous.",
  "note": "The manager replied that a decision would be made that week."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1630675894346948609",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1630675894346948609",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Tue Feb 28 21:06:44 +0000 2023",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/clur_sands/status/1630675894346948609",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "clur_sands",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "after_application",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "interview_or_screen",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "@brickywhat I have! Last time I was interviewing I had intros everywhere I applied except Postmates. Cold emailed the hiring manager and got an interview (I’d already applied but  still hadn’t heard anything a week later and wanted to get back on the radar)",
  "note": "A cold email after a week without news led to an interview."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1551646298335432704",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1551646298335432704",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Mon Jul 25 19:11:20 +0000 2022",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/Rhianim8or/status/1551646298335432704",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "Rhianim8or",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "direct_message_unspecified",
  "timing": "after_rejection",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "interview_or_screen",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "@DanEngler Well actually I DM’d the hiring manager and she said a recruiter should be reaching out soon because I shouldn’t have been kicked for not meeting the minimum.",
  "note": "The manager said the rejection was erroneous and that a recruiter should contact the candidate."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1538201473770823680",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1538201473770823680",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Sat Jun 18 16:46:24 +0000 2022",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/mackgiba/status/1538201473770823680",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "mackgiba",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "unspecified_direct",
  "timing": "internal_interest",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "reply_or_process_update",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "My company is hiring for a position in California. I reached out to the hiring manager regarding the position & she said she’d love to hire me. I asked the pay & she said $19/hr for a FULL TIME position but warned me it’s not enough to live in California…",
  "note": "The manager expressed willingness to hire, but disclosed pay too low for the location."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1529769237455200256",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1529769237455200256",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Thu May 26 10:19:42 +0000 2022",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/Lizzrr_/status/1529769237455200256",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "Lizzrr_",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "direct_message_unspecified",
  "timing": "after_application",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "interview_or_screen",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "Me. 2 week recruitment process/ 2 interviews and a presentation. \n\nI barely applied e bile. I simply messaged the hiring manager",
  "note": "The author reports a two-week process with two interviews after messaging the manager."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1506429317936566275",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1506429317936566275",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Wed Mar 23 00:35:12 +0000 2022",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/otonoshinkoito/status/1506429317936566275",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "otonoshinkoito",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "after_interview",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "no_response",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "@TheBlueOokami Yeah!! They told me they would get back to me in a week and they didn't so I emailed the hiring manager and still nothing 😭",
  "note": "The promised update did not arrive and the manager did not answer the follow-up."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1491195648007311360",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1491195648007311360",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Tue Feb 08 23:42:02 +0000 2022",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/SozaTweets/status/1491195648007311360",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "SozaTweets",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "after_rejection",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "feedback_only",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "As much as I post my wins, heres a loss I just received today, everything revolves on how you handle ur loss though\n\nin this case I emailed the hiring manager to see how I could’ve done anything differently to up my chances and they appreciate the effort. Ill be at Pfizer soon. https://t.co/VnaafO5m8H",
  "note": "The manager acknowledged a request for improvement feedback."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1486021066115928068",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1486021066115928068",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Tue Jan 25 17:00:05 +0000 2022",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/Scz4Prez/status/1486021066115928068",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "Scz4Prez",
  "contact_target": "recruiter",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "before_application",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "reply_or_process_update",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "I cold emailed a recruiter from IBM ( a black lady of course ) and she actually wrote me back . I think ima pass out . 😩😩😩",
  "note": "A cold email to an IBM recruiter received a reply."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1483462647182159872",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1483462647182159872",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Tue Jan 18 15:33:51 +0000 2022",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/shreyaaatha/status/1483462647182159872",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "shreyaaatha",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "unspecified_direct",
  "timing": "before_application",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "offer_or_hire",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "3. Reached out to the hiring manager when I was looking for work\n\n4. They agreed to my terms \n\n5. Joined. 1st week I was attending meetings where decisions were being made without any context/ formal induction",
  "note": "The author reports agreeing terms and joining after direct outreach."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1479162508644544514",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1479162508644544514",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Thu Jan 06 18:46:38 +0000 2022",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/erin_o_braugh/status/1479162508644544514",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "erin_o_braugh",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "after_final_interview",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "no_response",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "@TravisMayfield Had a final job interview & was 1 of 2 finalists. Was told I’d be notified of the decision within a week. A week went by & I emailed the hiring manager & never heard back. I had to go to their website to see that they’d put another person’s bio & photo to know I hadn’t gotten it.",
  "note": "The manager never replied and the candidate learned of the rejection from the company website."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1471489734820212739",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1471489734820212739",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Thu Dec 16 14:37:46 +0000 2021",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/hanbananzz/status/1471489734820212739",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "hanbananzz",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "before_interview",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "interview_or_screen",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "Anyway, I emailed the hiring manager and asked if we could sit down, have some coffee, and discuss the role. She seemed to really like me and wanted me to have a more formal interview with her team, and she seemed like she wanted to get it done this week before everyone leaves.",
  "note": "A coffee request led to a formal team interview."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1448855594111283214",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1448855594111283214",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Fri Oct 15 03:37:46 +0000 2021",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/ayeitsJOE_x/status/1448855594111283214",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "ayeitsJOE_x",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "unspecified_direct",
  "timing": "after_application",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "reply_or_process_update",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "I applied for a job, reached out to the hiring manager and she told me she’s holding my application 😭😭 like girl call me!! I need a fresh start",
  "note": "The manager replied that the application was being held."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1440114402850607108",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1440114402850607108",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Tue Sep 21 00:43:24 +0000 2021",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/sagastaki/status/1440114402850607108",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "sagastaki",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "linkedin",
  "timing": "after_recruiter_silence",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "reply_or_process_update",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "@IamKingFluffy I assumed I was not a fit for the job, which was fine. But after 2 emails to the recruiter with no response, I reached out to the hiring manager on LinkedIn to find out what had happened. Luckily he responded.",
  "note": "The manager replied after two unanswered recruiter emails."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1437465594308317188",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1437465594308317188",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Mon Sep 13 17:17:59 +0000 2021",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/TheBearHeir/status/1437465594308317188",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "TheBearHeir",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "after_rejection",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "rejection_or_negative",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "Well I didn’t get it, I reached out to the hiring manager and she said that my questionnaire wasn’t returned to her by email in time even though I sent it in the night before it was due at noon. \nSo system error somewhere fucked up my chance apparently. \nBack to the drawing board",
  "note": "The manager attributed the rejection to a questionnaire delivery failure."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1428065122430431232",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1428065122430431232",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Wed Aug 18 18:43:52 +0000 2021",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/coder_blvck/status/1428065122430431232",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "coder_blvck",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "unspecified_direct",
  "timing": "internal_application",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "offer_or_hire",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "Hehehe this! The current company I work for, put out a job vacancy and I reached out to the hiring manager who is currently my manager, and funny enough he told me he knows me and that he watched my talk at @DrupalConNA and liked it. The rest is history!",
  "note": "The author reports joining the manager's team after direct outreach."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1425472822026063881",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1425472822026063881",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Wed Aug 11 15:02:59 +0000 2021",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/HouseOfRachael/status/1425472822026063881",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "HouseOfRachael",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "late_process",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "offer_or_hire",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "Okay, I preach to people about being proactive.  I did just that - emailed the hiring manager for the other co and she responded! Offer letter coming later today.  The other company is fine, but my gut said this one is the right one.  So excited! Plus... Alabama unemployment /1",
  "note": "The manager replied and an offer letter was expected that day."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1412787678949613572",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1412787678949613572",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Wed Jul 07 14:56:45 +0000 2021",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/gabmonty/status/1412787678949613572",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "gabmonty",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "after_application",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "interview_or_screen",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "I applied for a dream job that I am very qualified for. After one week and no response, I did some light stalking and emailed the hiring manager. After another week with no response, I called her office, she answered😳 we talked, and I have an interview next week",
  "note": "Email received no reply, but a subsequent phone call led to an interview."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1408444367443013633",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1408444367443013633",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Fri Jun 25 15:17:59 +0000 2021",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/Perrsun/status/1408444367443013633",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "Perrsun",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "after_rejection",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "feedback_only",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "@FGC_Dad As always, Dad’s advice is universal. \n\nI recently went for a job interview. Didn’t get the position, but I emailed the hiring manager to set up a feedback session. Quick 15 minute call with them and now I know some gaps I can close next time.",
  "note": "The candidate obtained a 15-minute feedback call."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1407809092270362633",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1407809092270362633",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Wed Jun 23 21:13:38 +0000 2021",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/PersephoneK/status/1407809092270362633",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "PersephoneK",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "phone",
  "timing": "after_interview",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "offer_or_hire",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "@misfitpoise Sorry its such torture! I have been there. Once I didn't hear back about a job for 3 weeks and finally reached out to the hiring manager to thank him (assuming I'd been rejected). Immediately HR called me to offer job... hiring manager lit a fire under them.  :)",
  "note": "HR called with an offer immediately after the candidate followed up with the manager."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1400996131715354624",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1400996131715354624",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Sat Jun 05 02:01:21 +0000 2021",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/eels4reals/status/1400996131715354624",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "eels4reals",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "unspecified_direct",
  "timing": "after_rejection",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "offer_or_hire",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "@AbeRod1986 @the4shuffle @hansdickie This happened to me at my last job. Contacted the hiring manager to ask why I was rejected to find out I was selected immediately following my interview and HR made a mistake",
  "note": "The manager confirmed selection and identified an HR error."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1397728711638601729",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1397728711638601729",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Thu May 27 01:37:48 +0000 2021",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/adhidesign/status/1397728711638601729",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "adhidesign",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "after_interview",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "rejection_or_negative",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "@tranhelen In grad school, I interviewed for a full-time design role. They flew me in for the onsite. It went fairly well. A couple of weeks later, I emailed the hiring manager for an update since I had not heard back. He responded “the very fact we didn’t get back indicates our decision”.",
  "note": "The manager replied that silence itself indicated rejection."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1392220457470861316",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1392220457470861316",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Tue May 11 20:49:57 +0000 2021",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/EndUpTessa/status/1392220457470861316",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "EndUpTessa",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "before_interview",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "reply_or_process_update",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "I emailed the hiring manager about a position and she immediately responded and gave me her number to call in half an hour. It's missions systems so that's dope, but it's salary and I'm under qualified but what if she gives me a chance???",
  "note": "The manager immediately replied and offered a phone call."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1391782753700548611",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1391782753700548611",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Mon May 10 15:50:41 +0000 2021",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/gayatri_gt/status/1391782753700548611",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "gayatri_gt",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "linkedin",
  "timing": "after_application",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "offer_or_hire",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "I saw a job posting on Linkedin. I was very keen on the role and applied.\n\nI reached out to the hiring manager and asked him to review my CV and connect on a brief call.\n\nOne month, four rounds of interviews later, I got the job!",
  "note": "Direct outreach was followed by four interviews and a job."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1370094265053904900",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1370094265053904900",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Thu Mar 11 19:28:22 +0000 2021",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/07Cosmo/status/1370094265053904900",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "07Cosmo",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "late_process",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "offer_or_hire",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "I think I got the job. I emailed the hiring manager for an update and he told me every step he’s doing to get an offer letter sent ASAP... I doubt he’d tell me why there was a delay and he’s trying to get it this week if I wasn’t selected. https://t.co/J8dYYpQaMC",
  "note": "The manager described efforts to send the offer letter."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1350053518791598080",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1350053518791598080",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Fri Jan 15 12:13:36 +0000 2021",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/Maren_Bannon/status/1350053518791598080",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "Maren_Bannon",
  "contact_target": "department_head",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "before_interview",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "offer_or_hire",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "How I got my first job out of college? \n\nCold emailed the head of the department, who then passed my resume down to a hiring manager, who just assumed I was someone he should meet.\n\nDon't underestimate cold outreach 👩🏽‍💻✨",
  "note": "A cold email was forwarded to a manager and led to the author's first job."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1339031168151392258",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1339031168151392258",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Wed Dec 16 02:14:43 +0000 2020",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/miss_bushido/status/1339031168151392258",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "miss_bushido",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "before_interview",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "interview_or_screen",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "I emailed the hiring manager and after some back and forth (and more anxiety), I let him know I was free tmrw to talk between 11:30 and 1 (or we could keep emailing). He said he would call at 11:30, and added, “Please be available.” Like??? I will? I told you my availability?",
  "note": "An email exchange led to a scheduled call."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1232690170555781120",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1232690170555781120",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Wed Feb 26 15:33:33 +0000 2020",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/ThunderySteak/status/1232690170555781120",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "ThunderySteak",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "late_process",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "reply_or_process_update",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "Just found out why the company that was very eager to hire me suddenly went silent until I emailed the hiring manager today\n\n\"as of Friday last week I have been told to put a hold on hiring for the Dublin site until further notice\" https://t.co/adEf70P4jY",
  "note": "Follow-up revealed that hiring had been paused."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1220048829187350534",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1220048829187350534",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Wed Jan 22 18:21:22 +0000 2020",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/aystunz/status/1220048829187350534",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "aystunz",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "unspecified_direct",
  "timing": "missed_deadline",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "application_access",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "Something happened to me that perfectly describes this. I missed an application deadline, contacted the hiring manager to ask for an extension, she said yes & reopened it & extended the deadline just for me to apply.",
  "note": "The manager reopened and extended the deadline for the candidate."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1213276263374376960",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1213276263374376960",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Sat Jan 04 01:49:37 +0000 2020",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/shanas621/status/1213276263374376960",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "shanas621",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "late_process",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "no_response",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "@danielcrosby Was told that they would get back to me in a day or so with the finalized travel arrangements. I never heard from them again. I emailed the hiring manager & HR contact & never heard from anyone ever again. They ghosted me! 🤦🏻‍♀️",
  "note": "The candidate was ghosted after promised travel arrangements."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1147754196520726528",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1147754196520726528",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Sun Jul 07 06:28:19 +0000 2019",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/JustCBake/status/1147754196520726528",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "JustCBake",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "after_application",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "offer_or_hire",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "Margaritaville Night 2018, I applied for a job here with the @Aces . I immediately took a leap of faith and emailed the hiring manager. A year later and I’m working Margaritaville Night. I’m truly blessed. ⚾️🐠🌺 https://t.co/SISpHfssvF",
  "note": "The author reports working at the organization one year after direct outreach."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1045415058791182336",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1045415058791182336",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Thu Sep 27 20:49:07 +0000 2018",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/toukxa/status/1045415058791182336",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "toukxa",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "after_withdrawal",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "interview_or_screen",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "okay so i emailed the hiring manager about my application withdrawal from the position i interviewed for yesterday and for consideration for another and now i have to go talk to her tomorrow at 1pm i'm either lucky or extremely screwed",
  "note": "A message about another position led to a meeting the next day."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_1032009901491585024",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "1032009901491585024",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Tue Aug 21 21:01:48 +0000 2018",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/mwr_dbm/status/1032009901491585024",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "mwr_dbm",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "after_application",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "reply_or_process_update",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "After getting a \"no\" after 3 rounds interviews yesterday,\ntoday\napplied for an open position where I really want to work,\nemailed the hiring manager, to whom I happened to talk a year ago,\ngot a response I'd be considered for two openings.\nCohen.\nManafort.\nBEST DAY EVER!!! 🤩💃",
  "note": "The manager replied that the candidate would be considered for two openings."
},
{
  "evidence_id": "x_908418406927536131",
  "platform": "x",
  "source_type": "post",
  "source_id": "908418406927536131",
  "case_kind": "candidate_anecdote",
  "community": "",
  "published_at": "Thu Sep 14 19:53:20 +0000 2017",
  "source_url": "https://x.com/ChicagoanMess/status/908418406927536131",
  "source_title": "",
  "author_username": "ChicagoanMess",
  "contact_target": "hiring_manager",
  "relationship": "unknown",
  "channel": "email",
  "timing": "late_process",
  "message_mechanism": "",
  "observed_outcome": "reply_or_process_update",
  "highest_stage": "",
  "attribution": "direct",
  "text": "HR sent me an email minutes after I emailed the hiring manager. How are you doing???\n\nAre you kidding me? I'm dying over here!",
  "note": "HR contacted the candidate minutes after the manager was emailed."
}]